This summary text is fully AI-generated and may therefore contain errors or be incomplete.
Introduction
X is launching a handle marketplace allowing Premium subscribers to buy or rent inactive usernames for up to $1 million, creating a new revenue stream by treating desirable handles as digital real estate amid declining advertising income. The platform’s two-tier system offers both subscription-dependent rentals and permanent acquisitions, formalizing what was previously an underground market while raising questions about digital ownership and transparency.
Key Points
- Priority handles are subscription-dependent rentals that get revoked if users cancel Premium, while Rare handles costing up to $1 million are permanent purchases
- The marketplace prevents chaotic handle releases where bots historically snatched desirable names, instead allowing users to watchlist wanted handles
- X controls all pricing and prohibits handle transfers outside the platform, preventing users from becoming handle-flipping entrepreneurs
The Two-Tier Handle Economy
X’s new handle marketplace operates through a carefully segmented two-tier system available exclusively to Premium Plus and Premium Business subscribers. The Priority category includes full names, multi-word phrases, or alphanumeric combinations like @JohnSmith or @Lisa35, which users can request for free but must maintain their Premium subscription to keep. Cancel the subscription, and X revokes the handle after a 30-day grace period, effectively turning these usernames into subscription-dependent rentals rather than permanent digital assets.
The Rare handle category represents the premium end of this digital real estate market, featuring short, generic usernames like @Pizza, @Tom, or @One with prices ranging from $2,500 to over $1 million. X determines pricing based on cultural significance and demand, creating a valuation system that remains opaque to users. Unlike Priority handles, Rare handle purchases become permanent acquisitions that users retain even if they cancel their Premium subscriptions, though X explicitly prohibits handle-flipping by making all marketplace-acquired handles non-transferable and banning external sales.
Revenue Diversification Amid Advertising Collapse
The handle marketplace initiative represents X’s latest attempt to diversify revenue streams beyond traditional advertising, which has declined sharply since Elon Musk’s acquisition of the platform. By monetizing dormant usernames, X aims to capitalize on what research suggests could be a lucrative market—just 27 monitored accounts were previously able to generate nearly half a million dollars through handle flipping in unofficial markets. Now, X controls both the supply and pricing of this digital real estate, cutting out third-party intermediaries while capturing value that previously existed underground.
This isn’t Musk’s first attempt at monetizing inactive accounts. The strategy has evolved significantly since December 2022, when he announced plans to free up 1.5 billion inactive usernames. By November 2023, X was privately soliciting buyers at a flat $50,000 fee, and by April 2025, researchers suggested Verified Organizations could bid for handles starting at $10,000. The current marketplace represents the most sophisticated implementation yet, creating a structured economy around username acquisition that X hopes will drive Premium subscriptions among brands, influencers, and digital collectors.
Implementation Challenges and Controversies
The handle marketplace faces significant criticism for creating what detractors describe as a ‘digital caste structure,’ where users must maintain ongoing Premium subscriptions to retain their Priority handles. This subscription dependency turns usernames into rentals rather than permanent possessions for most users, raising questions about digital ownership rights. The system also lacks transparency around how X determines which accounts qualify as inactive and what recourse original owners have when their former handles are claimed by new users.
Historical precedents suggest potential conflicts over handle ownership. In 2023, X took the @x handle from photographer Gene X Hwang without compensation, simply notifying him that the company was claiming it. Similarly, Gemini CEO Cameron Winklevoss ‘ruthlessly took’ the handle @Cameron from crypto miner Cameron Asa, who had owned the handle for over ten years. Asa’s complaint that ‘the little guy always gets thrown under the bus’ highlights the power imbalance that could be exacerbated by the new marketplace system.
X frames the marketplace as solving long-standing user frustrations by preventing the chaos of open handle releases, where bots historically snatched desirable names within seconds. The platform now allows users to add specific handles to a watchlist and receive notifications when they become available. When users acquire a new handle through the marketplace, they preserve their followers, who are automatically migrated to the renamed account, while their previous handle is frozen and made unavailable to others—with X potentially offering redirect options for select accounts at additional cost in the future.
📎 Read the original article on decrypt.co