In a significant discussion, a former PlayStation executive shared insights into the crucial moment when FromSoftware decided to partner with Bandai Namco for the renowned Dark Souls series. This choice was influenced by dissatisfaction with Sony’s management of the release of Demon’s Souls, a game that, despite achieving cult status, encountered considerable challenges during its initial launch.
Challenges with Demon’s Souls
Demon’s Souls, developed alongside Sony Japan Studio, was released exclusively on PlayStation 3 in 2009. However, Sony’s choice not to publish the game outside Japan was shaped by internal playtest results that were viewed as unfavorable, along with skepticism regarding the game’s notorious difficulty.
The former executive expressed initial disappointment, recalling that after two hours of gameplay, he felt he was still at the beginning and described the game as “unbelievably bad.” This negative perception within Sony ultimately resulted in a lack of international support, prompting FromSoftware to explore other publishing options.
- Atlus handled the North American release.
- Bandai Namco took charge of the European market.
These alternative publishing routes allowed the game to establish itself and eventually gain a loyal following, despite the initial setbacks faced during its launch.
The Shift to Bandai Namco
The fallout from the handling of Demon’s Souls had enduring effects on the relationship between Sony and FromSoftware. The studio was already developing a sequel but chose to decline Sony’s collaboration offer due to their dissatisfaction with the previous experience.
This marked a pivotal moment, as FromSoftware aligned with Bandai Namco, leading to the release of Dark Souls in 2011. The franchise quickly became a cornerstone of the gaming industry, establishing the Soulslike genre and influencing numerous subsequent titles.
Repairing Relationships
Despite the initial rift, Sony eventually repaired its relationship with FromSoftware years later, resulting in the release of Bloodborne in 2015, a PlayStation 4 exclusive that received critical acclaim. The former executive expressed relief at the renewed partnership, praising Bloodborne as one of Hidetaka Miyazaki’s finest works.
However, the repercussions of past decisions lingered, as Sony never regained full control over the Souls franchise. Bandai Namco continued to publish the Dark Souls series, while a remake of Demon’s Souls was developed by Bluepoint Games and released for PlayStation 5 in 2020, further solidifying the game’s legacy.
FromSoftware’s Commercial Success
Since moving beyond its initial exclusivity with Sony, FromSoftware has achieved remarkable commercial success across various platforms. The release of Elden Ring in February 2022 marked a significant milestone for the studio, becoming their best-selling title to date, with over 28.6 million copies sold by September 2024.
This achievement underscores the studio’s ability to engage a mainstream audience and highlights the evolution of the Soulslike genre into a widely recognized and celebrated category within the gaming community.
The Impact of Elden Ring
Elden Ring’s expansion, Shadow of the Erdtree, further exemplified FromSoftware’s growing influence, selling over 5 million copies within just three days of its launch in June 2024. This rapid success reflects a broader trend in the gaming industry, where titles that once struggled for recognition can now achieve unprecedented sales figures through strategic partnerships and multi-platform releases.
The shift in FromSoftware’s trajectory serves as a case study in the importance of adaptability and the potential for redemption in the competitive landscape of video game publishing.
Lessons from the Sony-FromSoftware Saga
As the gaming industry continues to evolve, the lessons learned from the Sony-FromSoftware saga remain pertinent. The dynamics of publisher-developer relationships can significantly influence the trajectory of a franchise, and the ability to pivot and explore new partnerships can lead to unforeseen success.
The story of Dark Souls and its predecessors illustrates the intricate balance of creativity, business acumen, and market reception that defines the gaming world today.
📎 Related coverage from: gaming.news
